Thursday, 18 June 2009

  • Currently
    The Faith Club: A Muslim, A Christian, A Jew-- Three Women Search for Understanding
    By Ranya Idliby, Suzanne Oliver, Priscilla Warner
    see related

    Segregation...not just about race

    This is a subject that has been on my mind for a while now, but I wasn't actually inspired to write about it until today. And maybe there's a small chance I'll get flamed for this...but I'm not too concerned about that at the moment because this is a topic that needs to be addressed.

    I may be semi-known as an avid participant on Revelife but I was raised -- and, regardless of what anyone says, I am forever in my heart always -- Jewish. Throughout my upbringing I remember hearing phrases like "Jews can never go to church, only Christians do that," or "Jews can't have anything to do with Jesus, he's for Christians, not for Jews" and other such anecdotes. While I understand that logic, the result is problematic...rather than teaching a lesson on what Judaism is supposed to be, it creates a sense of alienation and segregation that results in ignorance and intolerance more than anything else.

    If Jews weren't allowed to read the New Testament, how would they be able to understand that Jesus was a man of peace and not someone who advocates violence in his name? If Christians weren't allowed to read the Torah, how could they understand why it's important to keep kosher and not do any work on the Sabbath? And if non-Muslims weren't allowed to read the Quran, how would we know that the perpetrators of 9/11 grossly misinterpreted their own text, making them think it's okay to crash airplanes into buildings that would ruin the lives of thousands of people? How can anyone expect world peace to come about any time soon if we all have these secret prejudices against reading other faiths' holy books, for the sole purpose of understanding why it is they believe what they do? Education is not wrong, people.

    As far as "traditional" Jewish upbringings are concerned, mine was fairly liberal and slightly untraditional. I missed several Sunday and Hebrew classes so I could participate in rehearsals for my town's annual Christmas pagaent (I was an angel but I always wanted to be Mary!). The first synagogue I remember going to was a church, which I was later Bat Mitzvahed in, much to the surprise of some of my Orthodox friends. I went to see The Passion of the Christ with my friend's church and participated in other interfaith activites that, for the most part, really broadened my spiritual horizon and helped clear up several misconceptions I had about the Christian faith. It wasn't until my senior year of high school that I picked up a copy of the New Testament and even then I felt strange about it, as if the imaginary Jew Police was going to sneak up on me and confiscate it, because it "wasn't my book."

    There is never going to be any peace without understanding, and understanding won't come unless people are willing to step out of their spiritual comfort zones and do some research to understand other people's religions. Otherwise, ignorance prevails, and we are not doing ourselves any favors by staying sheltered. Christians and Jews especially need to make more of an effort to understand each other, seeing how Christianity was born from Judaism, and no two religions are linked as closely as those two have been throughout history. In fact, Jesus never intended to create two separate religions...but I never would have known that if I had never bothered to read the "forbidden book" known as the New Testament. And I'm better off for having done so

Comments (5)

  • MagisterTom

    It's a miracle that you were able to read it and to be saved. Praise God for that.

    Even among Christians we are a segregated bunch, we segregate by denominations, race, age, etc. Regarding reading those other books though, it's something that needs to be done with prayer and discernment. I wouldn't give a ten year old a Q'uran to read as it may confuse them.

    And Christians do read the Torah! We just called put it in with the rest of the Old Testament. :)

  • sarahzthoughts

    @Tom@revelife - Well, maturity and the ability to use discernment are two key things to keep in mind. No way would I ever bombard my kids with a multitude of religious texts, that's too huge a task for anyone! But it's unrealistic to expect that we can effectively defend our faith to those who disagree without understanding where they come from. Many Christians I know seem to think that the Jews "rejected" Jesus because they just didn't like the guy, rather than looking up the reasons why Jews don't think he's the messiah. Christians probably wouldn't get such a bad rep if more of them -- and followers of any faith, for that matter -- took the time to do some research rather than just assuming that everyone is ignorant.

  • covereddindust

    hi!

    I think it is so awesome that you are saved coming from jewish roots, can you tell me more about your experience? How did your family react? Were you taught as a child that jesus was false, or was it never a big point? What convinced you that he was the messiah? sorry for being so invasive but i love reading about judiasm in the ot it's our history! thanksjauni
  • whatblokedoufancy117

    I think the feeling of segregation comes more from where you live. Where I live there are tons of Jewish people, so actually as a Christian I often times felt left out or like I wasn't allowed to do certain things. It's great you got all these opportunities though, regardless.

  • Struckanerve88

    i feel like i should prob start reading the bible and the torah just so i know more about it, while i don't really claim myself to any religion because, as you know, many religions take things too seroiusly or think you have to do this to be catholic or what not, it's prob more b/c i was raised mildly catholic more than anything. But i feel that being a good person is what matters not what religion you are and as long as you are a pretty good person i feel like things will turn out well for you in the end

    anyway i aggree with you sarah, like always

  • Choose Identity

  • Give eProps (?)

  • New! You can now edit your comments for 15 minutes after submitting.

Who recommended?

Who gave the eProps?